Editor’s Note: A recent online debate about AVMs highlights the many facets of this very important issue and underscores the wide divergence of opinion among appraisers about the place of AVMs in the lending process, and in the marketplace. The conversation was sparked by the story Copyright Appraiser Takes on AVMs. AVM Tango! Man or...…
Read More
Pennsylvania Case against AVMs (an Appraiser’s Summary of the Decision) by Tim Vining FIDELITY NATIONAL INFORMATION SOLUTIONS, INC., MARKET INTELLIGENCE INC., AND PENNSYLVANIA BANKERS ASSOCIATION, PLAINTIFFS v. GEORGE D. SINCLAIR, et.al., Defendants CIVIL ACTION NO. 02-6928 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA DECIDED MARCH 31, 2004 The purpose of this summary…
Read More
1
Editor’s Note: The bankruptcy earlier this year of the appraisal management company (AMC) ESA left millions in unpaid fees to appraisers, agents and brokers, who now are trying to collect from Chase, the bank who hired the AMC. What happens will have far-reaching effects on the appraiser-AMC relationship and the industry. Chase Denies Responsibility for…
Read More
In the wake of the GAO study, stake holders, including several appraisal organizations, have submitted comments to Congress. A joint letter from American Society of Appraisers, American Society of Farm Managers and Rural Appraisers, Appraisal Institute and National Association of Realtors writes: “With a patchwork of state laws and ineffective federal oversight allowing for only…
Read More
Title XI FIRREA: Finding the Framer’s Intent Buying a Lake in Arizona According to Doug Barnard, Title XI and appraiser licensing were a direct result of the savings and loan bailout in the early 1980s that cost taxpayers over $3 billion. The Subcommittee of Government Operations, Commerce, Consumer and Monetary Affairs held hearings all across...…
Read More
Editor’s Note: Support the in-depth and balanced reporting that your important industry deserves with a paid subscription to Working RE. Subscribe today ($30 annual) to guarantee delivery of Working RE and receive hundreds of dollars in discounts on education and other services! Special Edition: Appraisal Industry: A House Divided? AARO Mud fight, Run Away State...…
Read More
A move is underfoot to change the appraisal regulatory system. The first shot across the bow was fired by the Georgia Board, which is calling for the elimination of the Appraisal Subcommittee (ASC), among other things, and a shift from federal control to the states. Two respected appraisers, Frank Gregoire and George Hatch, take a…
Read More
Bye, Bye ASC? Appraisal Subcommittee Under Fire Is it Time to Start Over? You may already know that late last year the Georgia Appraisal Board, in a letter to Sen. Zell Miller, (D-Ga.), called for broad changes to the appraisal regulatory structure, including sun setting the Appraisal Subcommittee (ASC). What you may not know is...…
Read More
Editor’s Note: According to George Mann, there is lot of work appraisers can not engage because of a USPAP restriction- unless you live in one of three states. Appraiser Evaluations– Why Not? by: George R. Mann, MAI, SRA, MRICS I have worked at or with several top 20 banks and estimate that the annual volume...…
Read More
Success Collecting AMC Debt from Lender By David Brauner, Editor One appraisal company, at least, has collected monies owed by the now defunct appraisal management company (AMC) AppraiserLoft. How did they do it? They did it by citing chapter and verse of FIRREA. C. Brent Chitwood, office administrator for Phoenix Real Estate Appraisal in Irmo,…
Read More
