Category:
![]() | > The Appraiser Coach > Appraisal Institute > OREP E&O ★★★★★ “They are knowledgeable, professional, and understand urgency.” – Joe Thweatt |
Class Valuation Faces Class-Action Suit Over Appraiser Payments
by Frank Andorka, Managing Editor
Class Valuation, one of the largest appraisal management companies (AMCs) in the United States, is the latest AMC to be sued over the issue of appraisal fees and fee transparency.
Clayton Bernholtz, a Florida resident, filed a class-action lawsuit June 11, 2026, in Broward County Circuit Court against Class Valuation and CrossCountry Mortgage, alleging the companies overcharge consumers for home appraisals through undisclosed fees, in violation of the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act (FDUTPA).
Bernholtz also accuses Class Valuation of unjust enrichment, alleging the company pockets the difference between what it charges consumers and what it actually pays appraisers. He is asking the court to certify the case as a class action on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, which would allow other affected borrowers to join the suit.
Originally filed in Broward County, Florida, the case was later removed to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida (Case No. 0:26-cv-61978).
Many appraisers had hoped this issue would be resolved without litigation by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which had been expected to issue guidance before the new administration took over. In its current weakened state, it is unlikely such guidance will be coming, which leaves plaintiffs with no alternative but to sue.
Furthermore, the recent National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlement and litigation provided both motivation and inspiration for attorneys and consumers to sue over opaque fee arrangements.
Bernholtz’s case is the third pending class-action lawsuit that has arisen out of appraisal fee transparency, including Timmins v. Clear Capital, Core Valuation Management and Rocket Mortgage in California, and Arnold v. Appraiser Nation, also in Florida.
A fourth case, Golar v. Class Valuation LLC in Georgia, was dismissed without prejudice at the request of both parties.
The Allegations
Essentially, Bernholtz’s allegations echo the core arguments of the other class-action lawsuits facing AMCs and lenders in this space — CrossCountry Mortgage breached its contract with him, he claims, while Class Valuation, as an appraisal management company, engaged in “unlawful, unfair and deceptive practices relating to the ‘appraisal fees’ they charge mortgage borrowers.”
While buying a home is “one of the landmark financial burdens faced by Americans,” Bernholtz argues that saving up for the down payment is not the only burden on today’s potential homeowners. Additionally, the overwhelming closing costs can pose their own burden, especially when, as his lawsuit puts it, those costs “all too often are full of junk fees.” One such fee, he argues, is the appraisal fee charged to potential homeowners.
“While a borrower may pay an appraisal fee ranging from $450 to [more than] $1,000, the AMCs pay the appraiser only a fraction of this fee, deceptively keeping the remainder for themselves,” the lawsuit states. “The appraisers, not Defendants, perform the required appraisal. Class Valuation provides no tangible benefit to borrowers in the appraisal process.”
As other similar cases have argued, Bernholtz suggests the idea of hiding an AMC’s involvement flies in the face of what is purportedly a free-market system. AMCs are not required to compete in the marketplace the way that other vendors do, so consumers cannot shop for their services, nor do they know what the AMC will charge. The result is a dynamic where AMCs like Class Valuation have the opportunity to shop for the lowest-cost appraisal and then pocket the difference, Bernholtz suggests. While he understands that an appraisal of the property is necessary, Bernholtz believes AMC involvement should be disclosed at the time of the borrower’s loan estimate.
“In contrast, CrossCountry represents the appraisal fee as going to the appraiser,” the lawsuit contends, citing loan estimate language stating only, ‘We may order an appraisal to determine the property’s value and charge you for this appraisal.’ However, CrossCountry in fact charges for much more than the appraisal.”
Bernholtz is suggesting that he and a class of consumers (i.e., homebuyers who paid appraisal fees) “have suffered, and will continue to suffer, by being required to pay misrepresented, inflated ‘appraisal fees.'”
(story continues below)
(story continues)
The Facts
As Bernholtz points out, borrowers can’t shop for their own appraisers in most homebuying transactions. Instead, the lender picks an appraiser and bills the fee to the borrower, typically before closing. He contends the only way to completely avoid an appraisal fee is to pay for a home in cash.
Under federal law, appraisers and lenders must be separated to avoid another housing crisis like the one that devastated the industry in 2008. That’s the whole reason companies like Class Valuation exist, although Bernholtz argues companies like Class Valuation “provide no benefit to borrowers, and only a limited benefit to lenders like CrossCountry.”
The lawsuit goes on to defend appraisers, saying that it’s the appraisers who do all the work while the AMCs reap much of the benefits. It acknowledges that good appraisals take time and considerable effort and, as such, should be compensated fairly.
“Even though the AMCs provide no benefit to borrowers and have no apparent role in the actual appraisal services, the AMCs enrich themselves by obtaining inflated fees that far exceed the actual appraisal cost,” the lawsuit states. “Recent research indicates that [AMCs] typically retain more than 60 percent of appraisal fees. Stated differently, [AMCs] typically retain more than what they pay appraisers — meaning that borrowers’ appraisal fees are typically more than double the actual appraisal cost.”
As for CrossCountry Mortgage (the other named defendant in the lawsuit), Bernholtz argues they should have disclosed how much of the appraisal fee the AMC kept as opposed to what they paid the appraisers.
“Instead, CrossCountry forced plaintiff to pay an upfront fee of $700, representing that it was charging for only an appraisal, when it categorically was not,” the lawsuit says. “Instead, CrossCountry charged Plaintiff an appraisal fee and an undisclosed management fee.”
In closing, Bernholtz asks for the two classes to be split:
1) A breach-of-contract class against CrossCountry, on the theory that its loan estimate promised to charge borrowers only for the appraisal itself, not an undisclosed fee to Class Valuation; and
2) An FDUTPA class against Class Valuation, to recover the fees it collected from borrowers.
Class Valuation has asked for three extensions to prepare its defense, while CrossCountry Mortgage moved Aug. 14, 2026, to dismiss the breach-of-contract count against it with prejudice. In its motion, CrossCountry argues the loan estimate is a regulatory disclosure under the Truth in Lending Act, not a binding contract, and that even if it were, it’s unenforceable because it was never signed by CrossCountry, as required under Florida’s Banking Statute of Frauds. The lender also contends the loan estimate’s “we may order an appraisal” language is permissive and doesn’t restrict how it splits the fee with an appraisal management company, and that Bernholtz’s damages theory targets money Class Valuation allegedly kept, not any harm CrossCountry itself caused.
The motion doesn’t seek dismissal of the FDUTPA or unjust enrichment counts against Class Valuation. CrossCountry also points to Bernholtz’s closing disclosure, which shows he ultimately received a $50 credit against his $700 appraisal fee — evidence, the lender argues, that he didn’t overpay for his own appraisal.
At press time, CrossCountry’s motion to dismiss the breach of contract count remains pending before the court.
One way to address borrowers’ concerns — including Bernholtz and the plaintiffs in the other suits — is simple: Separate the AMC fee and appraisal fee in loan disclosures. This would disclose AMC involvement to the borrower early on and would transform the AMC fee into a flat fee, which would discourage them from paying the appraiser as little as possible.
Conclusion
Now that the courts have settled a class-action suit against the NAR in late 2024 over price-fixing and transparency of real estate agents, AMCs and lenders have taken notice. They can no longer be assured of prevailing, so they are watching these new cases with care and caution.
This case is just one of several working their way through the court system with the same goal in mind: forcing AMCs and lenders to be more transparent about how they bundle fees. Regulators haven’t intervened yet, but the more such cases are filed, the harder it becomes for them to ignore the issue. A win for Bernholtz could force greater transparency in appraisal fees — and put downward pressure on the fees AMCs collect going forward.
About the Author
Frank Andorka is the Managing Editor of Working RE magazine, published by OREP Insurance, a leading provider of E&O insurance for appraisers nationwide. Andorka has more than two decades of experience as a writer and editor and is based out of Cleveland, Ohio.
Tags: Appraisers, news editions





by Anonymous
I won’t comment on Class (though I do work with them and they can be quite frustrating), but I will say this is not a problem confined to Class. ServiceLink is another one that is extremely bad in this regard. In the past couple of months (particularly when things in my area have been slow and appraisers can be desperate for work) ServiceLink has given me the following jobs and payout schedules: (1) total charged to client $700, fee paid to appraiser $350, fee retained by ServiceLink $350; (2) total charged to client $2061, fee paid to appraiser $475, fee retained by ServiceLink $1586; (3) total charged to client $995, fee paid to appraiser $475, fee retained by ServiceLink $520. Really? The AMC whose job it is to hire the appraiser and do a minimalist review at the end keeping between 50% to 80% of the full fee? Is that “customary and reasonable”? Is that transparent? Does the borrower know what’s going on, and agree to that arrangement? This HAS to change.
-by Anonymous
Yes. Service Link also ranks up there with some of the worst. They don’t get enough credit for being overall terrible.
-by Anonymous
Having worked as a staff appraiser for an AMC, it was the worst professional experience of my 30+ year career. After getting laid off with a large national bank, I wanted to see what the deal was. Big mistake! After 9 months, I started looking to get out.
The AMCs are nothing more than a convenience for lenders so the lenders don’t have to staff their own appraisal departments. For the lenders, it is much easier to order on line with a 3rd party than to staff an entire department.
AMCs have destroyed the residential appraisal business and the sisters (FNMA/FMAC) are doing their best to put a final nail in the coffin.
Have you ever seen the layers and layers of employment in an AMC? From VP’s, to sales, to executive this and that, maybe if the same talking heads and so called “thought leaders” wouldn’t glorify themselves at all of their industry events and conferences, and actually acknowledge their business model is not fair to those who do the work and carry the risk, some progress could be made. Until that time, it will be the same hamster wheel while the best, most experienced appraisers say enough is enough.
-by Anonymous
I have a story to tell about Class. I was on their preferred appraiser list. I requested a fee increase for my work. They gave me the increase, then kicked me off that list. When I said I would waive the fee increase to get back on the list. They said no, they already had appraisers on their list who did work for that fee. Then proceeded to tell me, if I wanted back on that list, I would have to lower my fees to below what they were previously paying me to get back on that list.. When I said no, They quit sending me work. When I inquired as why why I was no longer receiving files from them, They said I was to difficult to work with.
-by Anonymous Old Timer
Class appraisals is just about one of the worst AMC’s out there, their fees are an insult. For eighteen years the AMC industry has been defrauding the consumer and engaging in wage theft so it’s about time they are held accountable. Too bad that for all these years nobody paid attention to what us appraisers are saying, that AMC’s should charge a separate management fee and not be allowed to keep a percentage of our compensation. BTW, another major issue is that if an AMC has staff appraisers then it is no longer functioning as a “Management” company, it is an appraisal firm just like the rest of us but with the unfair advantage of having direct access to the client when we are not permitted to do so.
-Bottom line, the AMC model as it exists is a form of legalized extortion and should either be completely reformed or eliminated altogether. I hope Mr. Bernholz takes Class for every penny he can get. It would also be nice if these AMC’s were forced to pay us appraisers back for all the fees they’ve ripped off over the years and continue to do so with impunity.
by Jared R.
The suit should include appraisers, who’s fees have been swindled in order to help pay the AMC. The AMC model makes it in their best interest to assign the appraisal to the cheapest appraiser, which harms the borrower, and the appraisers bidding assignments. Easy fixes going forward: 1) Separately disclose AMC and appraiser fee on the loan disclosure if an AMC is used; or 2) Don’t use the AMC at all. AMC’s are not necessary. Local agents and lenders know who the good appraisers are and should be able to choose an appraiser based on their history of delivering quality work, in a professional manner. I hear one of 2 things, poor quality work (not always due to a value issue), and poor business practices like not delivering when they promise, but the lender and borrower have no recourse because they can’t make a determination of who their list of reliable appraisers is.
-by Frustrated Appraiser
Appraisers sign away their rights by agreeing to the Vendor Agreements. Get appraisers to stop agreeing to that and then, maybe, there would a shot at a lawsuit.
-by Robert S. Abbott
They should broaden the lawsuit to include delays in closing times for loans. AMC’s notoriously slow things down. I just bid a job quoting 4 days. The BID doesn’t “close” for 6 days meaning the AMC can continue to solicit for new (lower) bids for days, beyond when they could have the report completed. And lenders use slow appraisal turns as justification for hybrid appraisal and AVM’s. IT ISN’T APPRAISERS SLOWING THE PROCESS … IT IS THE AMCs.
-by Anonymous
All AMC’s do this! As a staff appraiser for an AMC (still fee split arrangement), i have had a couple of occasions where the true fee was accidentally revealed on an order in my queue; the fee that was shared with me was $425, but the fee charged to the borrower was upwards of $600. When i asked about the discrepancy, I was blown off or avoided by anyone i asked. Yet we are powerless unless we actually sue, which is disgusting.
-by Threedotsix
You might have the best split of any staff appraiser in the entire industry. Congrats, and hopefully they don’t find this comment
Meanwhile, independent appraisers have spent years competing with staff appraisers working under a model that raises legitimate questions about independence. You may be completely unbiased in your work, but my concern is with the AMC staff appraiser model itself and the pressure it can create to favor the lender, whether that pressure is explicit or implied.
-by Frustrated Appraiser
Please contact ARCC, Appraisal Regulation Compliance Council. They may be interested in that info.
-