Where are You Advertising?

“I save your magazines and reference them when issues arise within the industry or my residential appraisal business. I find your publication to be very informative and worthy of archiving for future referencing.”
-Edward Rossi, State Certified  Appraiser

Advertising Information
Print: 80,000-90,000 Appraisers and Inspectors
Email: 45,000 Appraisers & 16,000 Inspectors  

Related Stories

WRE Subscribers and OREP Members have access to all stories at Workingre.com.
 

Current Issue (free access)

• Appraisers Talk, FHA Listens
• AMC Regulation: Good for What Ails You

Editorial Mission: to help readers grow as professionals and as business people.  WRE is published by OREP, E&O insurance experts.

• Your Comments Welcome  
• Advertising Inquiries
• Customer Service

If you enjoy WRE Online, please forward to a colleague. 

You are receiving WRE Online because you opted in at WorkingRE.com or purchased E&O insurance from OREP. WRE Online Edition provides news-oriented content twice a month. The content for WRE Special Editions is provided by paid sponsors. If you no longer wish to receive these emails, please use the link found at the bottom of this newsletter to be removed from our mailing list. 

If you are having difficulty reading this message, please read it online now:

www.workingre.com/workingre/hvcc-survey-results-appraisers-still-feel-pressure.html

Editor’s Note: Happy New Year! The Winter 2010 edition of Working RE is in the mail to 80,000 of you right now. You can also read it digitally by clicking the cover image (at left). There, you will have the opportunity to opt out of print for future editions, joining thousands of others in choosing to save the resources required to manufacture and mail their copies of WRE.  If you decide to opt out of print, we’ll let you know via email when each new issue is posted online.

Below you’ll find this issue’s cover story summarizing the effects of HVCC, according to the Working RE/OREP HVCC Talkback Survey. So far, over 4,300 appraisers have responded, making it the most comprehensive appraiser survey of its kind, including being quoted in an influential New York Times story, published last summer, which reported that over half of you still feel pressure from AMCs to make a deal work at least some of the time. (Find the NY Times story at WorkingRE.com, Sidebar: In Appraisal Shift, Lenders Gain Power and Critics.) The percentage reporting pressure has stayed steady in the months since, as you will read. If you haven’t participated yet, you can find the questions below and a link to the survey. The good news is that grassroots and feedback from the appraisal organizations and other interested parties are making a difference! We have no doubt that most appraisers will find their way in this new environment.

Looking Ahead/Looking Around
For eight years the mission of WRE has been to help readers grow as professionals and business people. True to our mission, you’ll find valuable stories in the new issue on how to find more work and how to be better appraisers. But we will not ignore what you are telling us, via the survey, about the effects of HVCC: the Code has turned the profession upside down while not solving the problems it was intended to fix- pressure on appraisers remains and, according to many, the quality of work is diminishing not improving. The most seasoned appraisers say they will not work under the present conditions and are leaving for greener pastures. This hurts everyone, including consumers and taxpayers.

Thousands of others say they want to continue appraising but may not be able to make a living on the new cut-rate fees or are unable to secure enough work from AMCs to stay afloat, now that they do not have access to their regular clients. The sad irony is that most of the protections in HVCC– which by all accounts are easing pressure and reducing complaints to some extent- existed before the Code was even a gleam in the eye of the New York State Attorney General.

(story continues below)

(story continues below) 

(story continues)
HVCC Survey Results: Appraisers Still Feel Pressure
By David Brauner, Editor

If you’re struggling to survive post HVCC; if you’re angry at having control of your business taken from you; if you’re having trouble getting orders from AMCs even though you’re trying; if you can’t make a living working for reduced fees; if your experience is that AMCs hire based on the lowest fee rather than quality work or if you continue to feel pressure to make deals work, then you’re not alone according to the OREP/Working RE HVCC Appraiser Talkback Survey and Blog.

With over 4,300 appraisers nationwide responding to the survey, the most significant results are that over half of the appraisers working with AMCs report that they continue to feel pressure to make deals work at least some of time.

Here are some quick stats. Find more complete results below:  

In the feedback we’ve received this year, perhaps the most gut wrenching are the many hundreds of emails that go something like this: “After 25 years I have gone through a lot of changes, been in and out of the professional organizations, worked for large institutions and have had three different, honorable fee shops in my journey. I somehow managed to gain approval with 45 major lenders and institutions and have never been blacklisted (that I know of), and never been sued. I have a solid reputation. I'm honest, hard working, and insist on providing my clients with only quality, comprehensive detailed reports. I don't think I have ever completed an assignment in less than three days (after inspection); I usually take five to seven. Nor have I ever been pressured to do so. I've established my own fees and built a clientele of honest mortgage brokers, banks, attorneys, and accountants, and have never been without work.”

The appraiser continues, “I have never worked for an AMC and will obviously/most likely not be able to. The HVCC is costing me 60-70% of my business and it is doubtful I will be able to survive financially. The cost of maintaining my now one-person practice will be prohibitive, unless by some miracle I find a situation that will cover the cost of my E&0, health insurance, data sources, office and auto expenses, etc. Well, I guess we could move back in with my parents. (I jest, I'm 52.) The loss of so many seasoned appraisers will be devastating but was it really necessary? For now I anticipate having to start over in a new profession, wish me luck.”

HVCC Moratorium
A bill that would impose an 18-month moratorium on the HVCC (H.R. 3044) was forwarded to the U.S. House of Representatives in June by Representatives Travis Childers, D-Miss., and Gary Miller, R-Calif., in reaction to complaints from appraiser constituents. This bill is in the first step in the legislative process, according to Govtrack.us. To weigh in visit Govtrack.us/congress/findyourreps.xpd to find your state representative and how to contact him or her.

·        Less than 5: 3%

·        5 to 10: 24%

·        10 or longer: 73%

·        Yes: 38%

·        No: 62%

·        Yes: 42%

·        No: 58%

Quality, Pressure, Fairness

·        Always: 51%

·        Often: 37%

·        Sometimes: 10%

·        Never: 2%

·        Always: 5%

·        Often: 14%

·        Sometimes: 43%

·        Never: 38%

>> Are the personnel at the AMCs you work with knowledgeable and competent?

·        Always: 2%

·        Often: 14%

·        Sometimes: 60%

·        Never: 24%

·        Always: 47%

·        Often: 37%

·        Sometimes: 14%

·        Never: 2%

·        Always: 22%

·        Often: 45%

·        Sometimes: 29%

·        Never: 4%

>> Do ‘low fees’ (from AMCs) effect the quality or completeness of the finished report compared with higher fee appraisals?

·        Always: 15%

·        Often: 18%

·        Sometimes: 26%

·        Never: 41%

Pressure

·        Always: 3%

·        Often: 11%

·        Sometimes: 40%

·        Never: 46%
 

·        Always: 33%

·        Often: 34%

·        Sometimes: 26%

·        Never: 7%
 

·        Always: 3%

·        Often: 12%

·        Sometimes: 41%

·        Never: 44%

Turn Times
>> With the AMCs you work with, do you experience pressure for turn around times that is unrealistic given the nature and scope of the assignment?

·        Always: 35%

·        Often: 42%

·        Sometimes: 19%

·        Never: 4%
 

·        Always: 15%

·        Often: 23%

·        Sometimes: 32%

·        Never: 30%

According to comments posted at the blog and survey, many appraisers doubt the profession can continue to attract competent professionals given the low fees, considerable expenses and licensing/training requirements. Many say they see greener pastures elsewhere.

As reported, 52% of survey takers say they don’t expect to be appraising fulltime five years from now but interestingly, 72% answer “yes” when asked if they are “generally satisfied with appraising.”

>> Are you making plans to leave the appraisal profession?

·        Yes: 45%

·        No: 55%

·        Yes: 92%

·        No: 8%

>> Is the data mining of your reports an important issue to you?

·        Yes: 91%

·        No: 9%

>> Is being ‘forced’ to submit your work through a third party entity and pay a fee to maintain a client relationship, an important issue to you?

·        Yes: 92%

·        No: 8%

·        Yes: 34%

·        No: 66%

Many appraisers say they intend to take back control of their profession and their businesses by working only with the AMCs that treat them fairly and by avoiding the ones that don't.

So far, these are the remedies most mentioned by bloggers and survey takers: appraisers must band together, put their differences aside and speak with one voice to put their interests forward. Many appraisers suggest a short, national boycott to demonstrate their importance to the system. Some say a fixed fee structure is necessary and/or a cap on the percentage of the appraisal fee AMCs may keep. One theme expressed over and over is that no one can make anyone work for low fees. The only way to fix this problem is to just say “no.”  

About the Author

David Brauner is Editor of Working RE magazine and Senior Broker at OREP, a leading provider of E&O Insurance for appraisers, inspectors and other real estate professionals in 49 states (OREP.org). He has covered the appraisal profession for over 16 years. He can be contacted at dbrauner@orep.org or (888) 347-5273. Calif. Insurance Lic. #0C89873.

Survey Questions - Click to take the survey now!

47. Do you carry E&O insurance?

48. Did we leave a good question out? If so, let us know below or email it to subsciption@workingre.com and we’ll have a look. If you have more to say on any of these topics, please visit out blog - www.orep.org/wordpress-2.7/wordpress/

New: Comment on this story at Working RE’s Appraiser Talkback blog. Join over 3,000 others and take the HVCC Appraiser Talkback Survey.

If you have questions, please email subscription@workingre.com.